American, Chinese and Japanese Mahjong
American Mahjong uses an annual card and jokers, Japanese Riichi uses yaku and furiten, and Chinese Mahjong includes many regional systems. Hong Kong and MCR are two distinct Chinese-style rulesets, not a single universal Chinese game.
Updated
Start with a family, not a universal rule
All these versions use related tile identities and a draw-discard rhythm. That shared language makes moving between variants possible, but it also creates traps. A call, flower or scoring assumption can feel familiar while being wrong for the table you have joined.
Ask which specific rules are being used. Chinese Mahjong is too broad to settle scoring or hand size across every regional tradition. This guide compares American NMJL play, Hong Kong, Riichi and MCR because they are covered on the site. It does not describe every regional Chinese or Taiwanese system.
American: card patterns and passing
American Mahjong normally uses 152 tiles, including eight flowers and eight jokers. Winning patterns come from the current annual card. The Charleston exchanges unwanted tiles before regular play. Flowers belong in hands, while jokers substitute only in eligible identical groups of three or more.
Do not apply the four-sets-and-a-pair rule as a universal American goal. Ordinary chow calls are not part of this system. Concealed and exposable card designations matter, as do suit and number relationships. Learn the card-reading system with your real card, since this site does not reproduce its protected hand patterns.
Hong Kong: sets, bonuses and agreed faan
Hong Kong play commonly uses 144 tiles, including eight flower and season bonuses. Most standard wins use four sets and a pair. Sequences are permitted, and a sequence call generally comes from the player to your left. Flowers are normally exposed and replaced.
Scoring varies across Hong Kong traditions and local tables. Minimum faan, flower treatment, caps and payments should be agreed before the deal. A common rule remembered from one group is not evidence that every Hong Kong table uses it. Bring a coherent scoring sheet rather than piecing together several unrelated charts.
Riichi: qualifying yaku and defense
Riichi uses 136 tiles without flowers or jokers. A hand needs a yaku to win, not just a completed structure. Dora can add value but cannot supply the yaku. Closed-hand choices, riichi declarations and the dead wall give the game its distinctive procedures.
Furiten changes what completing discards you may claim, making your own discard history important. Defensive decisions therefore become central, especially against a riichi declaration. Scoring uses han, fu and payment limits. Red fives, if used, replace ordinary fives rather than increasing the tile inventory.
MCR: defined scoring combinations
Mahjong Competition Rules use 144 tiles and 81 scoring patterns. A hand needs eight qualifying points, excluding flower points. Bonus flowers are counted separately. Permitted special shapes and restrictions on combining scoring patterns need to be read from the official definitions.
MCR is not simply Hong Kong Mahjong with a longer scoring table. Its qualification and combination rules can change which routes are practical. A hand that wins at a low-minimum Hong Kong table may fail MCR's threshold, while a pattern recognized in MCR may not have the same treatment elsewhere.
Choose what your future table plays
The best first version is often the one your friends, local club or preferred online group already use. Shared teaching support is more useful than a debate about which game is hardest or most authentic. Start with one rulebook and learn its basic legal winning conditions.
When switching variants, make a short checklist: tile inventory, bonus treatment, starting count, legal calls, winning structure, minimum value and payments. Keep familiar names from disguising changed permissions. The variant-differences lesson gives a compact comparison, and the individual guides explain each version in greater detail. Use the rules quiz to identify which assumptions belong to which table before trying a full game.
Questions at the table
Is Chinese Mahjong one ruleset?
No. It includes regional traditions and standardized systems. Ask which specific version your group plays.
Which version should I learn first?
Usually the version played by the people you want to join. A consistent rulebook and teaching partner matter more than a universal ranking of difficulty.
Sources and further reading
Keep learning
Need a set? Rack It! Mahjong